Satellites ?

Joined
Jul 5, 2016
Messages
572
Reaction score
165
Age
44
Since getting my drone back from DJI after stress crack repair, I noticed my sat. # has changed, from 17-20 down to 10-15.
What is concerning to me, if I put my hand ontop of the drone, about 2-3 inches away, not touching it, but my hand covering the top back, satellites go to zero.

Is there more then one GPS chip on this thing? is it possible they forgot to plug one in? This is enough for me to contact them and ask.
What else could it be? maybe they installed it wrong? bumped it?
 
could just be a fluke, I noticed mine dropped to 0 with my hand on top once. Just be glad she has gps lock
 
  • Like
Reactions: rkingsb353
There is only one GPS module and it is adhered directly to the top shell center.
Perhaps try moving to new a location. Use a GPS satellite tracker app to do a comparison.
 
As mentioned the GPS engine/antenna is centered in the top shell. It is to be expected that when covering this section with your hand that reception will be lost.
 
Since getting my drone back from DJI after stress crack repair, I noticed my sat. # has changed, from 17-20 down to 10-15.
That's completely normal (just like blocking the GPS antenna will block sat reception too).
The satellites aren't fixed in space but are all in different orbits.
The number in your sky is changing all the time.
4457788776_a0dafeec28_o.gif
 
That's completely normal (just like blocking the GPS antenna will block sat reception too).
The satellites aren't fixed in space but are all in different orbits.
The number in your sky is changing all the time.
4457788776_a0dafeec28_o.gif


This is interesting, but how often is that moving? if its monthly I would understand, but I doubt its monthly.. I fly at the same location at the same time, over and over ( I know boring )

it just seems strange that my sat. # has changed
 
This is interesting, but how often is that moving? if its monthly I would understand, but I doubt its monthly.. I fly at the same location at the same time, over and over ( I know boring )
it just seems strange that my sat. # has changed
The numbers visible anywhere are changing constantly.
From one hour to the next you would see the numbers changing.
 
here is a screen shot, of shield tablet #1 and shield tablet #2, #2 is being used for the phantom and #1 is using an app to locate satellites

DRONE#2 tablet
Screenshot_20160821-224646_zps3dougkl6.png



SAT APP#1 tablet
 
Last edited:
here is a screen shot, of shield tablet #1 and shield tablet #2, #2 is being used for the phantom and #1 is using an app to locate satellites
Unless it was intentional, your Phantom is set to over expose and your images will look washed out.
Use the right thumb wheel to dial it back from EV+1.3 to EV0 for proper exposure.
 
That's completely normal (just like blocking the GPS antenna will block sat reception too).
The satellites aren't fixed in space but are all in different orbits.
The number in your sky is changing all the time.
4457788776_a0dafeec28_o.gif
What does appear to be recent is the loss of GPS signal when you cover the top of the Phantom with your hand. This started out a couple of revs ago, maybe 1.5 or 1.6. It is unusual behavior because other consumer GPS modules seem to be more robust than that. My boat's 3 GPS receivers are under a fiberglass canopy and work fine. So does my iPhone. The P3, not so much.

It is possible that, because it's an aircraft and DJI has more stringent requirements as to what constitutes a valid signal that it seems to be more twitchy. But I would hope Lowrance (who makes my boat electronics) would also be rather concerned with accuracy.

But I think it was a firmware thing since it is consistent between all my P3s and didn't used to happen.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mikesmiley
thanks, just seems weird, I will admit when I take off , I get more satellites, as you can see I am getting 11, after about 2 minutes sitting on the ground (this was not after a take off, I already landed, just popped this battery in to compare)
It will sometimes get to 15, but it could and has dropped.

I need to do more testing, so I won't worry myself yet, I also asked DJI their thoughts
 
My boat's 3 GPS receivers are under a fiberglass canopy and work fine. So does my iPhone. The P3, not so much.

Fiberglass is transparent to RF signals . Human flesh (water/blood) is not. And neither is carbon fiber btw. Still, I agree its remarkable how quickly it loses all sats if your hand is above it.
 
On android, you can use app UAV FORECAST (UAV Forecast). The free version give 24h forecast for anything related to flying.
It will use your location to indicate the maximum number of satellites you can see.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dtitus6297
I know back in May I was receiving 15-17 satellites and now I am seeing 12-14 in august. Maybe its that time of year just a guess really lol.
 
You can also use Location Lookup to retrieve for a given location / time what satellites can be at best seen.
Don't forget it is as best value and there will be obstruction by buildings, tree, etc...
 
GPS signal strength on the surface is about -155dBW.
That's 1e-13mW or 0.00000000000000001 Watts!!!
It doesn't take much to block this signal.

Here's a 3rd-party explanation:
GPS Satellite Power Output

Achieving more sats in flight is due to the horizon expansion as you climb.
However this is limited by the antenna aperture and 'masking' where sats. near the horizon are ignored. Typically the mask is set about 5 deg. above the horizon.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Falcon900
here is a screen shot, of shield tablet #1 and shield tablet #2, #2 is being used for the phantom and #1 is using an app to locate satellites
One has to wonder why the device shows more sats connected than the P3?
My P3P infrequently does the same thing using the latest firmware. I'll be flying with 18-20 sats next thing u know I'll get a yellow warning telling me it's not safe to fly in Gps mode and I'll still have ~14 sats. A second later all the sats are back.
Brought the backup tablet with me the other day to watch sats while flying and it stayed steady at 19 sats. So again what's going on with the P3 gps?
It was a sunny day without a cloud in the sky and out in the countryside.

DRONE#2 tablet
Screenshot_20160821-224646_zps3dougkl6.png



SAT APP#1 tablet
 
I know back in May I was receiving 15-17 satellites and now I am seeing 12-14 in august. Maybe its that time of year just a guess really lol.
Solar activity has a huge influence on gps reception. Higher solar activity (Solar Flares) decreases the gps signal.

Sent from my SM-N920V using Tapatalk
 
Your comparing two different gps chips. Its like comparing apples to oranges. It would be more realistic to compare your signal with another identical drone.

Sent from my SM-N920V using Tapatalk
 
Solar activity has a huge influence on gps reception. Higher solar activity (Solar Flares) decreases the gps signal.

Sent from my SM-N920V using Tapatalk
That's true, this solar acitivity indicator Kp is also given by app UAV FORECAST (UAV Forecast).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ken Hanks

Recent Posts

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
143,090
Messages
1,467,565
Members
104,974
Latest member
shimuafeni fredrik